Mea Culpa. But I Can Explain.

Okay, so I was wrong. At least I wasn’t the only one.

Last month I wrote about how the expiration of the $8000 and $6500 tax credits for new home buying wouldn’t have much impact on the housing market. Those expired, for the uninitiated, on April 30, and since then sales on new homes have dropped to their lowest levels in history. So that wasn’t one of those really good predictions, and I’m sorry, and I admit I was wrong.

Pundits are saying that the drop is caused by buyers moving their purchases forward to take advantage of the tax credit, so that sales just moved from May to April. That surely took place. But at least here in my shop, there were a good number of people that couldn’t get the deal done in time, and who still are in the process of buying. That should have put some shims under the falling market.

So I have a different explanation for why what happened…happened. See, it wasn’t so much about the money. Markets are really smart. They compensate pretty fast for price-altering events like tax credits and artificial purchase incentives (see “Clunkers, Cash for”). When someone offers $8000 as an incentive for you to purchase a home, then the seller of that home adjusts his price upward to meet the new reality that you have more cash to spend, so most of the $8000 does you no good at all. As an aside, this is what the eggheads call “inflation”.

That did happen in this case, though not by anything like $8000 worth. No, the spike in home buying was not caused by the cash incentive as a dollar amount; rather, it was caused by the application of that dollar amount. As in, the $8000 was not a reduction in the price of the home; it was a boost in cash for down payment and closing costs. Yes, I know the government specifically said that the credit could not be used as a down payment. But, humans being what they are, and being waaaaaaay smarter than the government, they got “gifts” to cover the down payment and closing costs, then repaid those “gifts” with the tax credits. Voila! A temporary reinstatement of the zero-down loan programs the government killed last year.

The reason we’re in the economic mess we’re in is really quite simple: we borrowed too much money, and nobody saved a nickel. Now we can’t make the payments on the things we bought, so they’re being repossessed and foreclosed on. For a business, that means money is drying up and that means firings and layoffs. That exacerbates the personal financial problems, which means people stop spending, which further reduces the money for business, and around and around the mulberry bush.

If you have no cash, you can’t buy a home, because there are no zero-down programs outside of USDA Rural – which, not coincidentally, ran out of money 6 months before the end of the fiscal year – and Veterans’ Administration. But this program made it possible to fudge that, and brought a lot more buyers into the game. Until it ran out.

If you parsed the data, and nobody will actually give it to you so you can do this, but what you would find almost immediately is that the large majority of those tax credits were claimed by people whose down payments were smaller than the $8000 credit. Personally, I would bet that almost half of the loans that closed on which the credit applied were closed with gifts as the means of down payment. That was certainly true in our shop. I have no idea how many of those gifts were legitimate. Perhaps all of them. I hope so. But I doubt it.

Then, of course, the gravy train reached the terminus and everyone had to get off. Immediately, home sales dropped off a cliff. This doesn’t happen in market conditions where nothing hinky is going on. The market simply adjusts – prices fall, in this case – and people move on. Really, folks, the $8000 is not a big deal. It represents a payment increase of only about $40/mo for a borrower at today’s rates. That might have a small depressive effect on the market, but nothing like what we’re seeing.

Conclusion: the $8000 credit had the impact it did because it filled a market niche where there is huge demand, and that is the niche for 100% loans. The loss of the credit has taken out a very large part of the borrowing pool, those people that cannot come up with $7000-10,000 to put down on a house. Until something fills that gap again, don’t expect a huge market rebound.

11 Responses to “Mea Culpa. But I Can Explain.”

  • Or we just wait until we’re back to a society that saves money for their first home. It’s radical I know but it could happen.

  • Catherine says:

    I hope I don’t have to wait for that to happen to sell my house. I’ll be old and gray.

  • superbeets says:

    Your style is unique in comparison to other folks I’ve read stuff from. Many thanks for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I will just bookmark this blog.|

  • moncler says:

    My husband and i got quite more than happy that John managed to conclude his survey because of the ideas he received out of the weblog. It is now and again perplexing to just continually be freely giving points men and women might have been selling. Therefore we know we now have the blog owner to be grateful to for that. The type of illustrations you made, the easy website menu, the relationships you will make it easier to create – it’s got most superb, and it is aiding our son in addition to the family do think this matter is thrilling, which is tremendously serious. Many thanks for everything!

  • Thank you a lot for giving everyone a very superb possiblity to read critical reviews from this web site. It is often very beneficial plus jam-packed with a lot of fun for me personally and my office colleagues to visit your site particularly thrice per week to read through the new stuff you will have. Of course, I am also certainly pleased with your very good advice served by you. Certain two facts in this posting are essentially the most impressive we’ve had.

  • I precisely desired to say thanks once again. I’m not certain the things that I might have accomplished without the points provided by you relating to my industry. It had become a very troublesome problem in my position, nevertheless understanding a new well-written approach you managed it made me to jump for gladness. I’m just happier for your support as well as believe you realize what a powerful job that you’re getting into educating the others using your webpage. Probably you’ve never met any of us.

  • I intended to create you the very small observation in order to say thank you over again about the lovely methods you have contributed on this page. It has been really open-handed with you giving publicly just what a few people would’ve offered for an e-book to get some profit for their own end, most importantly now that you might well have tried it in the event you wanted. The good ideas likewise worked like the good way to be sure that other people online have similar fervor much like my own to see much more on the topic of this condition. I know there are numerous more pleasant instances up front for individuals who start reading your blog.

  • off-white says:

    I happen to be commenting to let you understand what a impressive discovery my daughter obtained going through your webblog. She picked up a lot of details, which include what it is like to have an ideal giving mood to let other individuals completely fully understand certain problematic subject matter. You truly exceeded people’s expectations. Many thanks for imparting such essential, dependable, revealing as well as easy tips on that topic to Mary.

  • I’m commenting to let you be aware of what a exceptional encounter my friend’s girl encountered reading yuor web blog. She noticed such a lot of details, with the inclusion of how it is like to have a great coaching character to let the mediocre ones really easily have an understanding of a number of problematic issues. You truly exceeded readers’ desires. I appreciate you for producing those powerful, trustworthy, educational and in addition cool tips about your topic to Sandra.

  • I must voice my affection for your kindness in support of individuals who really need assistance with this matter. Your very own dedication to getting the message throughout became really important and have encouraged workers like me to achieve their objectives. This valuable help and advice entails so much to me and still more to my colleagues. Thanks a lot; from all of us.

  • lebron 18 says:

    I definitely wanted to post a comment to thank you for those amazing techniques you are giving at this site. My time consuming internet investigation has at the end of the day been honored with pleasant knowledge to talk about with my colleagues. I ‘d say that we readers actually are very endowed to exist in a notable community with so many lovely professionals with good points. I feel truly fortunate to have encountered the site and look forward to so many more enjoyable minutes reading here. Thanks again for all the details.

Leave a Reply